The Smithereens - Tommy
7.5/10
ALBUM REVIEW

Tommy

by The Smithereens

Review of The Smithereens – Tommy

Released2009
ALBUM NOTES

Review of The Smithereens – Tommy

Tommy- Album Overview

The Smithereens released their album "Tommy" on June 20, 1994, as a tribute to The Who's iconic rock opera of the same name. This interpretation showcases the band's distinctive power pop sound infused with a modern sensibility while paying homage to the original. Released under the label RCA Records, the album features the skilled production of the band alongside the legendary producer, Ed Stasium, known for his work with artists like The Ramones and Living Colour. "Tommy" by The Smithereens includes tracks such as "Overture," "The Acid Queen," and "I'm Free," which are reimagined with the group’s energetic guitar riffs and melodic hooks. The decision to cover "Tommy" arose from the band's admiration for The Who and the desire to introduce the rock opera to a new audience. The album not only revisits classic tracks but also features the band's original songwriting flair, with the band members—Pat DiNizio, Jim Babjak, Mike Mesaros, and Dennis Diken—collaborating to keep the spirit of the music while exploring contemporary themes. Singles from the album, including "Pinball Wizard," received radio play and showcased the band's ability to reinterpret classic rock with their unique style. The significance of this album lies in its ability to bridge generational gaps, making a classic rock opera accessible to the 90s rock audience while celebrating the legacy of The Who.

Review

The Smithereens' "Tommy" is a bold reinterpretation that successfully captures the essence of the original while infusing it with the band's characteristic energy and melodic sensibility. The album’s sound is characterized by jangly guitars, driving beats, and rich harmonies that create a vibrant atmosphere throughout the tracks. Lyrically, the band remains faithful to the narrative of the original rock opera, exploring themes of isolation, trauma, and redemption, yet they manage to inject their own perspective, making it relevant to the 90s context. Pat DiNizio's vocals shine, delivering emotional weight that resonates with listeners, while the band's instrumental prowess adds depth to the arrangements. The artistic vision behind "Tommy" is commendable; it serves not just as a cover but as a reimagining that pays tribute to the source material while showcasing The Smithereens’ ability to breathe new life into classic rock.

Highlights

  • Energetic reinterpretation of classic tracks with a modern twist.
  • Strong vocal performance by Pat DiNizio, capturing the emotional essence of the original material.
  • Production quality that enhances the band's power pop sound while respecting the original rock opera's structure.


Weak points

  • Some purists may prefer the original version and find the reinterpretation lacking in certain emotional depths.
  • Occasional overproduction that might detract from the rawness of the original material.
  • Limited original songwriting, as the album primarily focuses on covers of the original tracks.


Overall evaluation

Overall, The Smithereens' "Tommy" is a commendable effort that successfully reinterprets a classic rock opera for a new generation while maintaining the spirit of the original. It showcases the band's musicality and respect for The Who, making it an enjoyable listen for both fans of The Smithereens and admirers of classic rock. Personal rating: 7.5/10
Selected tracks

Continue listening with music from the artist.

THE SMITHEREENS

More from the discography