That What Is Not

That What Is Not- Album Overview

"That What Is Not," the sixth studio album by Public Image Ltd. (PiL), was released in 1992, marking a significant point in the band's evolution since its formation in 1978. Released under the label, PiL Records, the album came after a five-year hiatus following their previous release, "9." The recording sessions took place in various locations, including the band's own studio in France, and featured a collaboration with producer and musician, Jonny Greenwood of Radiohead fame. The album's sound, a blend of post-punk and experimental rock, reflects the band's ongoing commitment to pushing musical boundaries while incorporating elements of funk and dub. "This What Is Not" includes notable tracks such as "Don't Ask Me," which became a single and received considerable airplay, and "The Body," showcasing the band's signature sound characterized by abrasive guitar riffs and John Lydon's distinct vocal style. The album's themes revolve around personal introspection, societal critiques, and the complexities of human relationships, often delivered through Lydon's confrontational and thought-provoking lyrics. Despite its mixed reception at the time of release, the album has garnered retrospective acclaim for its bold experimentation and remains a significant part of PiL's discography, resonating with both fans and critics alike for its artistic integrity and relevance in the ever-changing music landscape.

Review

The sound of "That What Is Not" is both dense and intricate, reflective of the band's trademark approach to composition. The production is layered, with a rich tapestry of sound that combines driving bass lines, sharp guitar work, and Lydon's unmistakable vocal delivery. Lyrically, the album traverses themes of disillusionment and existential angst, embodying the post-punk ethos with a contemporary twist. Tracks like "Don't Ask Me" capture the essence of frustration and confusion, while others delve into more intimate territory. Lydon’s vocals oscillate between a sneer and a vulnerable confession, creating a dynamic listening experience. However, some listeners may find the experimental nature of certain tracks challenging, as the album refuses to conform to mainstream expectations. Overall, "That What Is Not" stands as a testament to PiL's artistic vision and their refusal to play it safe, solidifying their place in the annals of alternative music history.

Highlights

• Innovative soundscapes blending post-punk with elements of funk and dub.
• Thought-provoking lyrics that challenge societal norms and personal introspection.
• Strong production quality that showcases PiL's musical evolution.

Weak points

• Some tracks may feel disjointed or overly experimental for casual listeners.
• The album's reception was mixed at the time, potentially overshadowing its merits.
• Lydon’s vocal style may not appeal to everyone, limiting broader accessibility.

Overall evaluation

In conclusion, "That What Is Not" exemplifies Public Image Ltd.'s fearless approach to music and their unwavering commitment to artistic authenticity. While it may present challenges for some listeners, its depth and complexity ultimately reward those willing to engage with it. The album remains a crucial chapter in the band's legacy, illustrating their continued relevance and influence in the realm of alternative music.