Paradise Lost - Icon
8.5/10
ALBUM REVIEW

Icon

by Paradise Lost

Listening guide: Paradise Lost's Icon

Released1993
ALBUM NOTES

Listening guide: Paradise Lost's Icon

Icon- Album Overview

Paradise Lost's "Icon," released in 1993, marks a significant turning point in the band's career and in the gothic metal genre as a whole. The album was released under the Music for Nations label and was produced by the band alongside producer, and engineer, Paul "Win" Winfield. Following the more death-doom sound of their earlier works, "Icon" introduced a more polished and accessible approach, blending elements of gothic rock and heavy metal. This shift is evident in tracks like "Embers Fire" and "True Belief," which showcase a darker, yet melodically rich sound. "Icon" features a total of ten tracks, including standout singles like "Forever Failure" and "Say Just Words," which received considerable airplay and helped elevate the band's profile in the early '90s metal scene. The album's artwork, created by the renowned artist, reflects the somber and introspective themes explored in the lyrics. Collaborators on the album include guitarist Gregor Mackintosh and bassist Stephen Edmondson, both of whom contributed to the songwriting and arrangement processes. Culturally, "Icon" is often credited with bridging the gap between doom metal and the burgeoning gothic rock movement of the time. Its impact on both genres is undeniable, influencing a generation of bands that followed. The album's exploration of themes such as despair, loss, and existential angst resonated with listeners, solidifying Paradise Lost's status as pioneers of the gothic metal sound.

Review

"Icon" presents a mature sound that showcases Paradise Lost's evolution as musicians and songwriters. The album is characterized by its atmospheric production paired with heavy, downtuned guitars and haunting melodies. The duality of Nick Holmes's growled and clean vocals adds a layer of complexity, enhancing the emotional weight of the lyrics. Lyrically, the album delves into themes of futility, disillusionment, and introspection, with tracks like "In This Depth" offering poignant reflections on human suffering. Musically, "Icon" balances aggression with melody, demonstrating the band's ability to craft memorable hooks while retaining their heavy roots. The guitar work is particularly noteworthy, with intricate solos and harmonies that elevate the compositions. While some fans of their earlier sound may have found this direction jarring, "Icon" has been embraced for its artistry and ambition, solidifying the band's place in metal history.

Highlights

  • Innovative blend of gothic rock and heavy metal elements.
  • Emotionally resonant lyrics that explore deep themes.
  • Strong production quality that enhances the overall listening experience.


Weak points

  • Some fans may prefer the heavier, raw sound of earlier albums.
  • Occasional pacing issues with slower tracks that might lose listener engagement.
  • Production choices may feel too polished for those seeking a grittier sound.


Overall evaluation

"Icon" is a crucial work in Paradise Lost's discography that marks their transition into a more melodic and accessible sound while retaining their gothic roots. It remains a landmark album in the gothic metal genre, influencing countless artists that followed. Personal rating: 8.5/10

Listen on Spotify

Selected tracks

Continue listening with music from the artist.

PARADISE LOST

More from the discography