First impressions of Melvins

ALBUM NOTES

First impressions of Melvins – Hold It In

Hold It In- Album Overview

The Melvins' "Hold It In," released on October 14, 2014, marks a notable addition to the band's extensive discography. This studio album was released under the Ipecac Recordings label, co-founded by Mike Patton of Faith No More fame. The album features the collaboration of Butthole Surfers guitarist Paul Leary, who not only produced the album but also contributed his unique sound to the tracks. "Hold It In" is significant as it showcases the band's ability to blend various influences, with tracks that oscillate between heavy sludge rock and psychedelic elements, reflecting their experimental ethos.

Comprising 12 tracks, the album includes standout singles such as "The Water Glass," which became a fan favorite and demonstrated the band's signature heavy riffs and off-kilter melodies. The recording took place in the band's home studio, allowing them to explore their sound without external constraints. The album is notable for its diverse sonic landscape, which includes the use of unconventional song structures and dynamic shifts that challenge the listener's expectations. This release continues the Melvins' legacy of pushing the boundaries of rock music and influences both established and emerging artists in the alternative and sludge metal scenes.

Review

Musically, "Hold It In" stands out for its willingness to experiment; tracks like "The Water Glass" and "Pissing" exemplify the band’s knack for juxtaposing heavy tones with melodic yet dissonant elements. The album also features a playful side, most evident in the absurdity of "Onions Make the Milk Taste Bad." This blend of seriousness and playfulness reflects the band's ability to not take themselves too seriously while delivering potent music. Overall, "Hold It In" is a testament to the Melvins' enduring creativity and their relevance in the ever-evolving music landscape.

Highlights

Innovative blend of sludge and psychedelic rock.
Strong production quality with Paul Leary’s unique touch.
Engaging and cryptic lyrical themes that invite interpretation.

Weak points

Some tracks may feel disjointed to casual listeners.
Experimental nature might not appeal to all fans of traditional rock.
Lengthy runtime may test the patience of some audiences.

Overall evaluation

"Hold It In" is a compelling addition to the Melvins' catalog that showcases their ability to innovate while remaining true to their roots. It balances heaviness with moments of surrealism, making it a worthwhile listen for both long-time fans and newcomers. The album's experimental nature may not resonate with everyone, but for those willing to embrace its unique sound, it offers a rewarding experience.

Personal rating: 8/10

Hold It In