Manchester Orchestra - A Black Mile To The Surface
8.5/10
ALBUM REVIEW

A Black Mile To The Surface

by Manchester Orchestra

Manchester Orchestra returns with A Black Mile To The Surface

Released2017
ALBUM NOTES

Manchester Orchestra returns with A Black Mile To The Surface

A Black Mile To The Surface- Album Overview

"A Black Mile To The Surface," released on July 28, 2017, is the fifth studio album by the Atlanta-based rock band Manchester Orchestra. This album marks a significant evolution in the band’s sound, moving toward a more expansive and introspective narrative style, coupled with a lush sonic backdrop. The album was produced by the band’s frontman, Andy Hull, alongside Grammy-winning producer Catherine Marks. Recorded in various locations, including the band’s hometown, "A Black Mile To The Surface" showcases contributions from an impressive array of collaborators, including the renowned musician and producer, Aaron Dessner of The National.

Thematically, the album explores deep personal and existential issues, reflecting Hull's experiences with loss and longing. The lead single, "The Gold," received critical acclaim and helped to introduce listeners to the album's intricate tapestry of sound. Other standout tracks include "I Know How To Speak" and "The Mistake," which further showcase the band’s fusion of alternative rock and indie sounds. The album's release through Loma Vista Recordings marked a pivotal moment in Manchester Orchestra's career, solidifying their presence in the contemporary rock landscape. The band’s willingness to embrace vulnerability in their lyrics has resonated with fans and critics alike, contributing to the album's cultural significance within the indie rock genre.



Review

With "A Black Mile To The Surface," Manchester Orchestra has crafted an album that is both sonically rich and lyrically profound. The production quality is a standout element, allowing each instrument to shine while enhancing Hull's emotive vocal delivery. The incorporation of varied instrumentation provides a dynamic listening experience, from the ethereal soundscapes in "The Gold" to the raw emotional weight of "The Maze." The lyrics are introspective, often delving into themes of hope, despair, and the complexities of human relationships, which are relatable and poignant. Hull’s storytelling ability is on full display, inviting listeners into a world that feels both deeply personal and universally resonant. Overall, the band has successfully pushed the boundaries of their sound while remaining true to their core identity, making "A Black Mile To The Surface" a compelling entry in their discography.



Highlights

  • Intricate and layered production that enhances the band’s sound.
  • Emotionally resonant lyrics that tackle personal and existential themes.
  • Strong collaborative efforts that elevate the overall musical experience.


Weak points

  • Some listeners may find the slower tempo of certain tracks less engaging.
  • A few songs may come across as overly introspective for casual listeners.
  • The album’s cohesive sound might not appeal to fans of their earlier, more aggressive work.


Overall evaluation

"A Black Mile To The Surface" stands as a testament to Manchester Orchestra's growth as artists, embracing vulnerability and depth in their music. This album not only showcases their evolution but also solidifies their place in the modern rock landscape. A must-listen for fans of introspective rock.

Personal rating: 8.5/10

Listen on Spotify

Selected tracks

Continue listening with music from the artist.

MANCHESTER ORCHESTRA

More from the discography